My grammar book pointed out that when you use some verbs in the continuous tenses, it need to be something active, such as running, or eating. Verbs that do not imply an action, but instead refer to a state of affairs - for example, know, own, love, or feel -can not be used in the continuous tenses. If so, is there any verb list which I can not use in the continuous tenses? It makes me confuse and easily make mistake if I am not careful. So as native English speaking people.
Asked
Active
Viewed 2,075 times
1
-
Not entirely correct. "Feel" can be used in the present tense: "I am feeling [object]." – Dog Lover Jul 18 '15 at 03:26
-
I think you're being too restrictive in your use of the progressive form of verbs. – deadrat Jul 18 '15 at 03:40
-
I"m not sure about the general claim concerning verbs that do not imply an action. "I'm sitting here" sounds OK to me even though sitting isn't an action. But I agree that "I'm loving it" is not something one would ordinarily say. That might be why it was chosen as a slogan; things we don't ordinarily say attract more attention. – Andreas Blass Jul 18 '15 at 03:44
-
So do you think my grammar book's explanation is not correct? – teizoartjewelry Jul 18 '15 at 03:46
-
Also, most people do not even notice about this slogan's grammatically wrong. Of course, they do not say it but they do not care grammar of this phrases. – teizoartjewelry Jul 18 '15 at 03:51
-
If your grammar book is any good, it should say the progressive tense is not normally used for stative/non-action verbs. I'm guessing the book is aimed at pre-intermediate, possibly intermediate level learners. An advanced level book will not make such a black and white statement. Remember that English is incredibly flexible, and it is constantly mutating. It is a living creature that survives in today's world, and no longer leans towards or looks upon Latin for guidance. – Mari-Lou A Jul 18 '15 at 04:48
-
1related: Verbs not normally used in the present continuous and on the web: Non-continuous Verbs and "Non-Continuous Verbs,"... These verbs are usually things you cannot see somebody doing. These verbs are rarely used in continuous tenses. – Mari-Lou A Jul 18 '15 at 04:59
-
1Your grammar book has most likely over-simplified and over-generalized the grammar "rules" that it's teaching the students. The grammar is not that simple. There are usages and contexts where that type of construction is acceptable. I think Language Log might have done an article on that topic. :) – F.E. Jul 18 '15 at 05:59
-
Seems like the author of your grammar book needs to take an English course. – Misha R Jul 18 '15 at 08:02
-
@Mari-LouA nailed it with her link to: http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/6582/im-lovin-it -- high five for her; nicely done. – Father Luke Jul 18 '15 at 08:46
-
Here's a related article: http://chronicle.com/blogs/linguafranca/2014/03/27/are-you-feeling-it/ – F.E. Jul 18 '15 at 20:51
4 Answers
2
I agree with F F. Your grammar book over-simplifies. I am thinking. I am thinking doughnuts. I am feeling hot. I am hearing dissent. I am considering love. I am loving the memory. I am remembering it. I am loving it (so long as the pronoun "it" has been defined by the previous text). I am having no difficulty with any of these!
Anton
- 28,634
- 3
- 42
- 81
-
What about something much more similar than yours: "I am hating it". Sounds a bit off, somewhat like the over progressive-izing by Indians like "I am wanting to go home now". – Mitch Jul 18 '15 at 20:32
1
What matters for whether you can use the progressive is whether a verb refers to a process. States are not processes, but actions are ordinarily processes. Processes needn't be actions. Processes take some time to happen. Radioactive decay of uranium is an example of a process that is not a condition and is not an action -- you can perfectly well use the progressive aspect to describe it: "The uranium is decaying rapidly."
Greg Lee
- 17,406
0
col·lo·qui·al
kəˈlōkwēəl
(adjective)
Used in ordinary or familiar conversation; not formal or literary.
synonyms: informal, conversational, everyday, nonliterary; unofficial, idiomatic, slangy, vernacular, popular, demotic
"He was puzzled by the colloquial language of the advertisement."
If so, is there any verb list which I can not use in the continuous tenses?
Not so much a list so much as a special usage: colloquial.
I hope that helps.
Father Luke
- 490
0
Your grammar book is correct. You would say, "I love grammar," but you wouldn't say, "I am loving grammar." Below are other examples of non-continuous or stative verbs, which don't have a progressive aspect. Many advertisements use incorrect grammar to be cute (and sell hamburgers).
feeling: hate, like, love, prefer, want, wish senses: appear, feel, hear, see, seem, smell, sound, taste communication: agree, deny, disagree, mean, promise, satisfy, surprise thinking: believe, imagine, know, mean, realize, recognize, remember, understand other states: be, belong, concern, depend, involve, matter, need, owe, own, possess
Zan700
- 3,376