2

Here's the sentence:

As I walked through the exhibit, I overheard a visitor remark, "You know, that grandfather clock actually runs."

The "subject" of the verb is singular ("visitor"), so if remark is functioning as a verb, it should agree with the subject (whether it's considered past or present tense), so I'm guessing it's serving as a modifier of some sort. Can anyone expound on this?

Dan Bron
  • 28,335
  • 17
  • 99
  • 138
dean
  • 23

1 Answers1

2

It’s a bare infinitive (a.k.a. the simple form of the verb).

  • What’s the subject of your main clause?  I
  • What’s the primary verb in the main clause?  overheard
  • Is the verb transitive or intransitive?  transitive
  • What’s the direct object?  ?

Ay, there’s the rub!  The direct object is the phrase, a visitor remark, “You know, that grandfather clock actually runs.”  Things get a little weird when a phrase with a subject and a verb acts like a noun.  We have a list of how to handle those at When should a verb be followed by a gerund instead of an infinitive?  That page doesn’t mention overhear, but it does state that hear (and see) are followed by either the simple form or the gerund (no “to”).

It may make more sense if you consider shorter sentences:

  • I heard him sing.
  • I heard him sing the anthem.
  • I saw him play.
  • I saw him throw the ball.
  • I overheard him remark blah blah blah.

As indicated above, you can also use gerunds for these verbs:

  • I heard him singing.
  • I heard him singing the anthem.
  • I saw him playing.
  • I saw him throwing the ball.
  • I overheard him remarking blah blah blah.
  • Scott, I cannot thank you enough for your time in responding! I'd been struggling with that quite a bit. You are bona fide grammar god for explaining that in such easy to understand terms. Much appreciated! (Hoping this message will get to you before I delete this shortly to abide by the site suggestions.) – dean Sep 04 '17 at 21:38
  • Thank for the thanks (and for the checkmark), but I’m not even a demigod around here.  Yes, I know grammar somewhat better than the average person (and I mean in the world, not on this site), but mostly I just happened to remember that thread from seven years ago, and I just happened to be the first one to get to your question. Enjoy [SE] (and, yes, follow the rules, or people will get upset). – Scott - Слава Україні Sep 04 '17 at 21:55
  • Perhaps worth nothing that the use of a gerund puts greater focus on the actual performance of the action, rather than the action as a whole or the subject of that action, as is the case with the infinitive. – heathenJesus Sep 05 '17 at 14:29