- to forgive is a great value
- Forgiveness is a great value
- Forgiving is a great value
Does meaning change ? And why ? Grateful to your help
Asked
Active
Viewed 72 times
0
samir nour
- 11
-
4Does this answer your question? Using Nouns or Gerunds The to-infinitive is rarely used as a subject (and then mostly twinned with a second infinitive), but is literary in style ('To see her is to love her'). – Edwin Ashworth Aug 27 '20 at 10:57
2 Answers
0
Not all verbs would comply with the -ness version. "To hit", for example.
"Smoking is injurious to health." -- certainly sounds better with the gerund than it would with the infinitive "to smoke". Likewise with a big set of verbs-- where "infinitivizing" them doesn't sound proper (encourage, enjoy, dread, deny, keep, etc. are some such verbs).
The non-finite variety of the English language amplifies its charm and were we to whittle it down to only a certain set of constructions, it wouldn't be as live and vivacious a language as it is.
-
1Sometimes the infinitive sounds better: to live is to suffer, or living is suffering? To obey is to enjoy or obeying is enjoying? There is a slight difference in meaning between the gerund and the infinitive which means that sometimes one sounds better and sometimes the other does. – Peter Shor Aug 27 '20 at 12:57
-
Thank you @Peter Shor for enhancing my answer. I should have used these examples to zero in on my point, but thanks nonetheless! :) – Aug 27 '20 at 13:00
-
-1
You ask a subtle question. I will try to give the sense of the slight differences that I see. I hope others will forgive me if they see things differently. I already forgive them for their inevitable criticisms!
The action of forgiving is a great value
The personal quality of a tendency (or inclination) to forgive is a great value
Any specific act of forgiveness is of great value.
Anton
- 28,634
- 3
- 42
- 81
-
-
Kind of you. But perhaps the person who marked it down would like to give their reasons? We may learn something from them. – Anton Aug 27 '20 at 15:36