What do you think of these sentences? I found them on the Net. I mean, should they function here as a gerund or a participle? Are both of them possible? 1 Smoking cigarettes are dangerous 2 Smoking cigarettes is dangerous
Asked
Active
Viewed 149 times
0
-
I'd say that "smoking cigarettes" is a non-finite gerund-participial clause functioning as subject of the sentence. Non-finite clause subjects take singular agreement, so only 2. is correct. – BillJ Jun 21 '21 at 17:21
-
1Flying aeroplanes can be dangerous. – Edwin Ashworth Jun 21 '21 at 18:00
-
Does this answer your question? Gerund and participle comparison – Edwin Ashworth Jun 21 '21 at 18:02
-
@BillJ If the first one is correct (read warning about bush fires in Oz), the head is the noun cigarettes and smoking is an attributive modifier. – Araucaria - Him Jun 21 '21 at 19:12
-
Yes, but discarded lit cigarettes are usually called "lighted (or burning) cigarettes", not "smoking cigarettes*. – BillJ Jun 22 '21 at 04:46
1 Answers
2
2 is correct, as "smoking cigarettes" is a gerund phrase, acting as a noun/subject in the sentence. However, 1 can also be correct if what you mean is that cigarettes that are burning (having smoke coming out of them) are dangerous things. :)
soysoymilk
- 307