The right word for obstructive bureaucracy

Question

I'm looking for a word but I'm not sure it exists. Is there any word that resembles something like obstructive bureaucracy?

What I actually mean with this: Someone who blocks an extremely urgent request on the basis of bureaucracy.

An example:

Harry, Chief of the Fire Department, didn't send out the fire trucks to the fire because the caller didn't fill in form A34.

What is this type of behaviour called?

Are you asking about a term to refer to the *person who does this,* or *the act of doing this*? — Andrew Leach, Jan 18 '22 at 09:10
@AndrewLeach I sharpened the question, thanks for your feedback. — S B, Jan 18 '22 at 09:12
This isn't exactly the same but may help: Idiom for someone who got a tiny fraction of power and abuses it?. There are a couple of other questions that aren't quite the same, although it's not clear exactly what is being asked. — Stuart F, Jan 18 '22 at 09:12
@SB Great: thanks. The person who does this is a jobsworth. Perhaps the "act" is "being a jobsworth", although a single word would be nice. — Andrew Leach, Jan 18 '22 at 09:14
Is there any word that resembles something like obstructive bureaucracy?. I'd suggest the word bureaucracy. I cannot recall (aged BrE writing) nor immediately find, any use of the word with other than negative resonances. And now I can look forward to others on this site digging those out! — High Performance Mark, Jan 18 '22 at 09:29
Related: kafkaesque. As far as I know, this can't be applied to individuals, though. — Joachim, Jan 18 '22 at 10:06
Also blind compulsive adherence to the rules regardless of circumstance [closed] — Edwin Ashworth, Jan 18 '22 at 12:54
@DjinTonic In addition to your link, there are numerous duplicates on ELU found by searching for redtape — Mitch, Jan 18 '22 at 13:37
Apologies for the closing snafus. I was able to reclose and chose as duplicate the one with the most answers applicable here. To the OP, this is a good question, but it happens to have been asked and answered many times so we redirect you there. — Mitch, Jan 18 '22 at 13:50
Closure was apparently justified but if the question were a true duplicate I would expect to find duplicate answers. However, on a quick look I did not find my own suggestion of Beadledom in existing answers. Unless I missed something, the closure has therefore denied the site of a small extra dimension to the original answers. This does not seem productive and the closure runs counter to the aim of extending knowledge. Anyone have any views on this? — Anton, Jan 19 '22 at 10:40

Anton · Accepted Answer · 2022-01-18T23:20:51.710

1

The only word I think of that fits your specification is beadledom:

Collins

beadledom:
Noun
fussiness and stupidity of minor officials; petty bureaucracy

YourDictionary

fussiness and stupidity of minor officials
petty bureaucracy
beadles collectively, and their characteristics as a class
stupid or senseless officiousness

Merriam Webster

the characteristics felt to mark beadles as a class
usually stupid officialism

The beadle is typically a low level bureaucrat:

Cambridge

beadle:

an official who takes part in some church or university ceremonies
in the past, an officer of the law who dealt with small offences in a local area

Such officials, lacking the reflective capacity of high lever officials, tend towards over-enthusiastic, pompous, self-important and unthinking application of rules and regulations.

Hence, one of the strongest associations of the beadle with this sort of behaviour was in Charles Dickens's OliverTwist. The refusal of food to a hungry child seems to qualify as denial of an urgent request rather well.

Fandom

Mr. Bumble, fictional character in the novel Oliver Twist (1837–39) by Charles Dickens. Mr. Bumble is the cruel, pompous and ignorant beadle of the workhouse where the orphaned Oliver is raised. Bumbledom, named after him, also characterizes the meddlesome self-importance of the petty bureaucrat.

Consequently, google's ngram shows the word to have been at its most popular in the latter half of the nineteenth century.

Anyone familiar with the adventures of Michael Bond's Paddington Bear (https://www.paddington.com/us/heritage/michael-bond/) will also find beadledom in the behaviour of the officious self-appointed custodian of street affairs Mr Curry:

edited Jan 18 '22 at 23:20

answered Jan 18 '22 at 10:40

Anton

28,634
3
42
81

1

The only problem with beadledom is that no one who has not read your erudite answer will understand what it means! – High Performance Mark Jan 18 '22 at 11:25
@HighPerformanceMark Thanks for the compliment. Isn't this the case with a number of answers on this site? We have to assume an educated, tolerant and reflective readership or we risk failing our questioners. Not easy. – Anton Jan 18 '22 at 11:54
Worth an upvote as it's absent from the duplicates. – Edwin Ashworth Jan 18 '22 at 12:55
1

@EdwinAshworth I am not persuaded that the answers in the original "duplicate", although many and well voted, are quite right for this question. However, it is nice to feel praised with faint damns. – Anton Jan 18 '22 at 13:18
@Anton While this is a good find, HP Hark's comment is a necessary comment, pointing out that an SWR answer here should not only provide the word but explain the conditions of its use, like how common it is, if it is local (AmE or BrE or nautical or medical or etc etc), register (formal informal), taboo, etc etc etc. Basically the things that a dictionary rarely supplies. – Mitch Jan 18 '22 at 13:43
Wow nice, that's a sharp answer. I will wait accepting your answer as to see what else might come in. – S B Jan 18 '22 at 14:07
'I am not persuaded that the answers in the original "duplicate", although many and well voted, are quite right for this question.' No, they don't fulfil the 'block[ing] an extremely urgent request on the basis of bureaucracy' condition. But then neither does 'beadledom'. – Edwin Ashworth Jan 18 '22 at 16:13
@EdwinAshworth Asking for more food when almost starving might just be seen as urgent by most of us. That is one of the aspects of the beadle in Oliver Twist, is it not? I thought this to be well known but have added to the answer for completeness. – Anton Jan 18 '22 at 23:17
The etymological fallacy. There have been many beadles besides Bumble. M-W has merely 'stupid officialism'. I haven't come across any mention of extreme urgency. – Edwin Ashworth Jan 19 '22 at 17:00

The right word for obstructive bureaucracy

1 Answers1